Michel de Montaigne (1533–1592) is a French Renaissance thinker, often considered the father of the modern essay form. His Essays (Essais) are personal reflections on everyday life, combining personal experience, philosophy, and classical learning. In "On Repentance," Montaigne explores the idea of repentance, but not in the religious or moralistic sense most people think. Instead, he talks about accepting oneself as one is, acknowledging one’s nature, and living truthfully.
Explanation of "On Repentance":
1. Human Beings Are Naturally Imperfect
Montaigne starts by emphasizing that imperfection is a natural part of being human. He says we are mutable (constantly changing) and contradictory — it is in our nature to have flaws and to change over time. So, expecting perfect virtue or moral consistency from humans is unrealistic.
He writes, "I do not portray being; I portray passing," meaning he portrays himself in motion — evolving, not as a fixed self.
2. Authenticity over Repentance
Montaigne criticizes the idea that we should always be repenting for who we are. True authenticity is to accept oneself fully, rather than constantly trying to apologize for one’s nature.
Repentance, in the traditional religious sense (like sorrow for sins), assumes that there is a “perfect” version of ourselves we have failed to achieve. Montaigne disagrees — there is no "ideal" self we fall short of. We are simply ourselves.
He writes, "I rarely repent, and that is because I very rarely promise," meaning he does not make big moral promises he cannot keep, so he does not have to repent for failing them.
3. Change Is Natural, but Our Core Self Remains
While Montaigne acknowledges that people do change (their opinions, actions, moods), he believes there is a fundamental core personality that remains the same.
We should own who we are, including our inconsistencies. Repenting for these is like denying the essential truth of our being.
4. Critique of Hypocrisy
Montaigne criticizes those who present a false image of themselves to the world. Many people pretend to be more virtuous or pious than they are.
Montaigne says it is better to admit our faults openly than to cover them up with false repentance.
5. Self-Knowledge and Acceptance
Montaigne promotes self-knowledge — understanding and accepting your true nature. Instead of striving for impossible perfection and feeling guilty about falling short, we should aim to live genuinely according to who we are.
6. Repentance Should Only Be for Betraying Oneself
The only real cause for repentance, Montaigne says, is betraying your own nature — acting against your inner truth.
If you are deceitful, hypocritical, or fake, then you should repent. But if you live truthfully, in accordance with your nature (even if it is flawed), there is no need for regret.
Key Quotes and Their Meaning:
- "We are all patchwork, and so shapeless and diverse in composition that each bit, each moment, plays its own game."
Humans are complex and made of contradictions.
- "I am not responsible for the world’s fashion: to be proud of being able to do without repentance is no less absurd than to be proud of being able to do without any sickness or infirmity."
Repentance is like sickness — a natural human occurrence, but nothing to be proud of or ashamed of.
In short:
Montaigne's "On Repentance" challenges the traditional Christian idea that human beings must constantly repent for their sins. He believes we should accept our human nature, live authentically and truthfully, and not be ashamed of being imperfect. Repentance is only necessary if you have been false to yourself, not because you are naturally flawed.
Thank you!
0 Comments